The Student Experience is Changing, but the Challenges Persist: What Senior Student Affairs Leaders Need to Know
November 18, 2026
AI is reshaping how students approach college, but financial insecurity, mental health challenges, and gaps in institutional support remain significant barriers to student success.
For student affairs leaders, recent higher education reporting tells a connected story: while technology is changing how students learn, access information, and navigate college, the fundamental conditions that support student success remain largely unchanged. Students’ financial security and well-being cannot be addressed in isolation, and institutional support systems are not reaching as many students as they should.
New findings from Inside Higher Ed’s 2026–27 Student Voice survey and the Hope Center for Student Basic Needs at Temple University point to an important leadership challenge: Are institutions keeping pace with the changing student experience while adequately addressing the needs that continue to affect persistence?
1. Innovation and Technology Cannot Substitute for the Foundational Conditions Students Need to Succeed
Inside Higher Ed’s November 17 Student Voice findings reveal that AI is becoming a regular part of the college experience. Eight in 10 students report routinely using generative or agentic AI. While approximately one-third say these tools help them study more efficiently and better understand difficult concepts, 30% say they rely less on professors or tutoring centers for academic assistance.
Yet technology is not addressing students’ most persistent challenges:
- Mental health concerns, including stress, anxiety, and depression, remain the leading reported barrier to academic success (41%), followed closely by financial pressure (37%).
- Sixty-one percent of students reported going without at least one essential, such as food, housing, or transportation, because of cost.
- While 81% of students rate their education as good or excellent, only 24% are highly confident in their institution’s efforts to keep that education affordable.
These findings align with key leadership takeaways from NASPA’s recent AI Summit. Throughout the summit, panelists emphasized that innovation matters, but technology cannot substitute for the foundational conditions students need to succeed. Leaders should consider how emerging technologies can foster greater human connection, accessible support, and student-centered services.
2. More Institutions Offer Emergency Aid, but Fewer Students Receive It
Emergency aid programs are growing, but student access tells a different story. Inside Higher Ed reported that the share of NASFAA member institutions operating emergency aid programs increased from 35% in 2020 to 52% in 2025. Yet the share of students reporting that they received emergency aid fell from 44% in fall 2021 to just 4% in fall 2025, according to Hope Center analysis.
Perhaps most concerning is the gap between what institutions offer and what students know:
75% of student success administrators say their institution offers emergency aid
21% of students say their college offers it (62% aren’t sure)
13% of students know how to apply
7% of students have accessed it
In a recent Inside Higher Ed article, Jhenai Chandler, NASPA’s vice president for research, policy, and student success, emphasized that student health, safety, and well-being cannot rest with a single office or initiative. Emergency aid and one-stop support models are essential, she noted, but NASPA’s data show they:
“often lack the capacity and resources to meet the scale of student need.”
Having a program is not the same as delivering effective support. Institutions must examine whether students know about available resources, can access them, and receive help when it matters most. For a closer look at how campuses are structuring this work, see NASPA’s Connecting Emergency Aid With Student Success: 2026 Landscape Analysis Findings.
The Bottom Line
The question is not simply whether we are keeping pace with how students experience college. It is whether we are addressing what students need to succeed once they get here. Together, these findings point to three priorities for senior student affairs leaders:
- Connect innovation with human-centered support. As institutions explore AI for advising, financial aid guidance, and success coaching, ensure technology improves access without creating new barriers or replacing meaningful human interaction.
- Use institutional data to make the case for investment. Track emergency aid applications, unmet need, funding availability, and recipient persistence. Pair this data with student feedback to strengthen budget requests and state and federal advocacy.
- Treat student well-being as institutional infrastructure. Connect financial aid, basic needs, well-being, advising, and student success initiatives through cross-divisional partnerships, consistent funding, and leadership accountability.
Resources Referenced
- NASPA: Connecting Emergency Aid With Student Success: 2026 Landscape Analysis Findings
- NASPA: 2026 Top Issues in Student Affairs Follow-Up Brief: Health, Safety, and Well-Being
- Inside Higher Ed: “As AI Changes How Students Approach College, Old Challenges Persist” (Nov. 17, 2026)
- Inside Higher Ed: “Rebuilding the Student Safety Net” (Oct. 15, 2026)
- Inside Higher Ed: “The Disappearing Student Safety Net” (July 28, 2026)
Go Deeper With NASPA Research
2026 NASPA Top Issues in Student Affairs
Seventy-five percent of VPSAs who responded to the survey said addressing basic needs insecurity is very important to their institution this year, an eight-percentage-point increase from 2025. VPSAs shared that they are leading this work by:
- Developing sustainable funding strategies, including fundraising
- Collaborating with divisions and departments institution-wide and determining whether to establish a centralized basic needs center
- Identifying, building, and expanding relationships with community partners to leverage community resources
- Collecting data on students’ needs beyond housing and food
- Using student feedback to identify gaps and target interventions
Connecting Emergency Aid With Student Success: 2026 Landscape Analysis Findings
Emergency aid serves as a timely and impactful institutional resource for students facing unexpected financial challenges that can disrupt their ability to persist. The 2026 NASPA Emergency Aid Landscape survey collected detailed information about emergency aid programs nationwide. Explore the interactive report to learn about:
- The types of emergency aid offered at colleges and universities nationwide, along with the annual budget and primary funding source for each type
- Cross-departmental collaboration to deliver emergency aid support, and the number of institutions with centralized basic needs centers
- Which campus and community-based follow-up services are most beneficial to students experiencing basic needs emergencies
- Which expenses beyond housing and food qualify for emergency aid, and which expenses are most often identified in requests
- How institutions collect the data needed to advance emergency aid programs
Emergency Aid Case Study Report: Lessons Learned From 2025–2026 Campus Microgrant Recipients
Through sponsorship from TIAA, NASPA awarded $10,000 to five institutions to provide emergency aid resources directly to students. Institutions in the 2025–2026 cohort shared their innovative approaches (download the full report (PDF)):
- Community College of Aurora pairs emergency aid with personalized coaching support.
- LaGuardia Community College operates a highly collaborative, centralized “one-stop-shop” CARES model that connects students with financial counseling and wraparound services.
- University of Houston-Downtown expanded emergency aid for child-related expenses and created a family-friendly resource center that fosters community and peer support for pregnant and parenting students.
2026 Top Issues Follow-Up Brief: Health, Safety, and Well-Being
Addressing student health, safety, and well-being is an enduring priority for student affairs professionals. Explore the interactive brief to learn about:
- How student affairs leaders and their teams are collaborating institution-wide to foster a holistic approach to student health, safety, and well-being, including examples from two universities
- Research-to-practice resources related to substance abuse prevention, basic needs and student support, campus-wide health promotion, and student health data
- NASPA toolkits that offer guidance on student substance abuse prevention and well-being efforts and can be incorporated into staff training
- Developing federal and state policy related to student health, safety, and well-being, plus the NASPA Public Policy Hub, with policy trackers, articles, fact sheets, legislative summaries, and videos on state and federal legislative and policy changes
Well-Being as a Strategic Priority (Leadership Exchange, Spring 2026)
- The emerging role of senior wellness officer has evolved to lead well-being efforts on campus, with approximately 160 such positions across colleges and universities today.
- The most effective well-being leaders have convening authority, manage cross-functional teams well, and communicate skillfully. They also use data to inform decision-making and resource allocation so their teams can succeed.
- Well-being leaders at all levels must be equipped to advocate for constituents, lead across diverse groups, and commit to advancing health equity.